Columbus Day and Hispanics graphic: the truth many were never taught

Columbus Day and Hispanics: The Truth Many Were Never Taught

Written by: Mónica Malavé, CEO of Elevate It Now®, on Columbus Day Christopher Columbus, the Taíno people,[…]

Written by: Mónica Malavé, CEO of Elevate It Now®, on Columbus Day

Christopher Columbus, the Taíno people, Puerto Rico’s colonial history and the stories that deserve to be remembered. · Cultural Context · October 2026

The Columbus Day Story Many of Us Learned

If you grew up in the United States, chances are you remember learning about Christopher Columbus in elementary school. There were pictures of three ships, stories about a brave explorer and that familiar rhyme: “In 1492, Columbus sailed the ocean blue.” It was a simple story. Columbus sailed across the Atlantic, discovered America and changed the world.

But what about the people who were already here? What about their families, their communities and the traditions they had built long before European ships appeared on the horizon? That is the part of the story many of us didn’t learn in school.

For many Hispanics, especially those with Indigenous Caribbean ancestry, Columbus Day brings up a history that looks very different from the one celebrated in classrooms and parades. It is a history marked by colonization, forced labor, enslavement, violence and the devastating loss of Indigenous lives. And it raises a question worth asking: why celebrate someone whose arrival helped set those events in motion?

Of course, not every Hispanic or Latino feels the same way. Some observe Columbus Day, others recognize Día de la Raza or Indigenous Peoples’ Day, and many don’t commemorate the date at all. Still, to understand why Columbus remains such a controversial figure, we need to look beyond the familiar story of three ships and a discovery.

Columbus Day and the Myth of an Empty America

Let’s start with something that should be obvious but somehow gets lost in the traditional telling. America wasn’t empty when Columbus arrived. The Smithsonian’s Native Knowledge 360° resource states that Indigenous peoples have lived in the Western Hemisphere for tens of thousands of years, and that Columbus was not the first outsider to reach the Americas and did not “discover” them.

These weren’t people waiting to be discovered. They had their own histories, leaders, beliefs and ways of life. In the Caribbean, the Library of Congress describes the Taíno as a sophisticated people with complex religious, political and social systems. They were skilled farmers and navigators who wrote music and poetry and made expressive objects, and they were the most numerous Indigenous people of the Caribbean when Columbus arrived.

Yet the story many of us learned centered almost entirely on Columbus. How can someone discover a place where people are already living? It’s a reasonable question, and one that deserves more attention whenever we talk about this holiday.

The Taíno People: What Happened After Columbus Arrived?

For Puerto Ricans, Dominicans, Cubans and other Caribbean communities, this history isn’t distant or abstract. It’s connected to the people who lived on the islands long before they became Spanish colonies. The Library of Congress places the Taíno in present-day Cuba, Jamaica, Haiti, the Dominican Republic, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands.

They grew crops such as cassava, traveled between islands, created ceremonial objects and developed artistic and spiritual traditions. Their communities had leadership systems and relationships that connected people across the Caribbean. So what changed?

An expanding system of Spanish colonization followed the first encounters between Europeans and Indigenous Caribbean communities. Spanish colonizers took land and resources, forced Indigenous people into labor and brought warfare, displacement and disease. Colonial authorities removed people from their villages to work for them. Agricultural production suffered, families split apart, and communities struggled to keep the systems that had supported them for generations.

European diseases, against which Indigenous populations had little prior immunity, added another devastating dimension. The Library of Congress notes that by 1550 the Taíno were close to extinction, largely because many died of diseases the Spaniards brought. A Smithsonian Magazine article on the Taíno living today describes the loss of about 90 percent of the Native population after European arrival.

It’s important to be precise here. Columbus didn’t personally carry out every abuse that occurred during centuries of Spanish colonial rule. However, his expeditions and administration helped establish the colonial presence that made those later developments possible. That distinction matters, because the documented history is disturbing enough without exaggeration.

The Darker Side of Columbus: Enslavement, Forced Labor and Violence

When people remember Columbus as an explorer, the conversation usually focuses on navigation, ambition and the historical significance of crossing the Atlantic. His actions as a colonial administrator deserve attention, too.

Indigenous enslavement

Columbus and his associates participated in the enslavement and forced transportation of Indigenous Caribbean people. As Spanish colonial activity expanded, Indigenous communities increasingly faced demands for labor and resources. For the people affected, these weren’t simply changes in government or trade. They meant losing control over their work, their homes and, in many cases, their freedom.

Forced labor and the search for gold

Gold was a major objective of early Spanish colonial activity. Colonial demands compelled Indigenous people to work, including in mining and agriculture. The effects reached well beyond the people doing the labor. When colonizers took farmers and other community members away, villages lost the people they depended on. Food production declined, families lost one another and existing social structures became harder to maintain.

Violence and population decline

European conquest also brought armed conflict, coercion and systems of control that profoundly changed Indigenous societies. Disease played an enormous role in population decline, but it wasn’t the only factor. Forced labor, hunger, warfare and displacement made an already devastating situation worse. Historians continue to study the size of Indigenous Caribbean populations before European contact and the precise scale of the losses, and those estimates vary. What is clear is that the social and demographic consequences were catastrophic.

The destruction and transformation of Indigenous institutions

Colonization changed far more than political boundaries. It disrupted traditional leadership, religious practices, economies, languages and relationships with ancestral lands. Colonial authorities suppressed some traditions, and others changed as communities adapted to colonial rule. But there’s another part of this story that deserves just as much attention: Indigenous culture did not disappear entirely.

The Taíno Didn’t Simply Disappear

For years, the story told about the Taíno often ended with one word: extinction. It’s a convenient ending for a textbook, but it doesn’t capture the full history. Indigenous Caribbean populations suffered devastating losses. Still, descendants survived through generations of intermarriage, migration, cultural adaptation and community continuity.

Science has added to this picture. A 2018 study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, reported by Smithsonian Magazine, sequenced ancient DNA from a woman who lived in the Bahamas centuries before Columbus. Researchers compared it with 104 present-day Puerto Ricans and found about 10 to 15 percent Native American ancestry, with clear similarities to the Taíno. The article cautions that how much of that reflects Taíno ancestry is unclear, but the findings support the view that the Taíno did not vanish.

Today, people in Puerto Rico, the Dominican Republic, Cuba and throughout the diaspora identify with and preserve Taíno heritage. Smithsonian Magazine’s reporting on Taíno identity also notes that the Taíno movement grew in the 1970s and that some scholars dispute claims to Indigenous identity. That debate is part of the story, and it deserves respect from every side.

For Puerto Ricans, this is especially meaningful. Our identity reflects centuries of interaction among Indigenous, African and European peoples. That mixture has given us an extraordinary cultural heritage, but it also emerged from a history that included enslavement, colonization and inequality. Acknowledging that history doesn’t mean rejecting the culture that developed afterward. It means understanding it more completely.

Why Columbus Day Is Particularly Complicated for Puerto Ricans

Puerto Rico has its own deeply personal connection to this history. Columbus arrived on the island in 1493 during his second voyage. But Puerto Rico, known to its Indigenous inhabitants as Borikén, was already home to Taíno communities. Spanish settlement began in 1508, bringing changes that reshaped the island’s political, economic and cultural life, along with forced labor, disease and displacement for Indigenous communities.

For Puerto Ricans who recognize their Indigenous ancestry, Columbus can represent the beginning of a painful chapter rather than an occasion for celebration. That doesn’t mean every Puerto Rican views the holiday in exactly the same way. Our families, education, experiences and understanding of history shape our perspectives. Still, the events that followed European arrival are an essential part of Puerto Rico’s story.

El Morro: a familiar landmark with a colonial history

Anyone who has visited Old San Juan knows El Morro. Its enormous stone walls, sweeping ocean views and distinctive garitas are among the most recognizable images of Puerto Rico, and it’s a place many of us take pride in. But have you ever thought about why it was built?

Panoramic landscape of historical castle  San Felipe del Morro "El Morro" along the coastline, San Juan, Puerto Rico

According to the National Park Service, construction began in 1539, just 46 years after Columbus reached the island. Spain chose the site for its strategic position at the entrance to one of the Caribbean’s best harbors, and the fort would deliver heavy artillery fire on enemy ships. The Park Service calls it “the gateway to the Spanish empire” and notes that it became a World Heritage Site in 1983.

The fortress wasn’t built to honor Columbus or specifically to control the Taíno population. Its purpose was to protect San Juan’s harbor, shipping routes and Spanish colonial interests against rival European powers. We can appreciate its beauty, history and cultural significance while also recognizing what its construction represented. El Morro reminds us that European colonization wasn’t simply about exploration. It was also about establishing authority, controlling territory and defending imperial interests, all on an island Indigenous people had called home long before Columbus arrived.

Our Indigenous heritage is still part of everyday life

The influence of the Taíno is woven into Caribbean culture in ways we sometimes take for granted. Consider words such as hamaca, canoa and huracán. Smithsonian Magazine notes that hurricane and hammock are credited to Taíno, and the Library of Congress says Taíno influence survives in the beliefs, religions, language and music of Caribbean cultures. The same Smithsonian article describes traditions such as building bohíos, tending conucos and making casabe. These connections are worth remembering, especially when discussions about Columbus focus almost entirely on European exploration.

Culture shapes communication

Let’s Build Marketing That Respects Your Community

Our bilingual and bicultural approach helps businesses communicate with authenticity, accuracy and respect.

Why Do Some People Still Celebrate Columbus Day?

The controversy is complicated, in part because the holiday means different things to different communities. In the United States, Columbus became an important symbol of Italian American heritage. Italian immigrants and their descendants experienced discrimination, and celebrations honoring Columbus became one way for communities to recognize their contributions and establish a sense of belonging.

The history of the observance is long. According to a Congressional Research Service fact sheet, New York City hosted the first unofficial celebration in 1792, and President Benjamin Harrison issued the first official proclamation in 1892. Congress asked the President in 1934 to proclaim Columbus Day each year, and a 1968 law set the second Monday in October. Today, federal law asks the President to issue an annual proclamation, and 5 U.S.C. 6103 lists it as a legal public holiday.

For some Americans, the holiday represents Italian American identity and the historical significance of transatlantic exploration. For others, honoring Columbus overlooks the experiences of Indigenous peoples who suffered during the colonial expansion associated with his voyages. Both histories deserve to be understood. Recognizing the discrimination faced by Italian Americans doesn’t require ignoring Indigenous suffering, and acknowledging the consequences of colonization doesn’t diminish the contributions of Italian American communities.

Columbus Day, Día de la Raza and Indigenous Peoples’ Day

Indigenous Peoples’ Day shifts the focus from European exploration to the people who inhabited the Americas long before European arrival. It recognizes Indigenous histories, cultures, survival and contemporary communities. That last point matters, because Indigenous peoples aren’t simply part of a distant historical chapter. They are living communities whose cultures continue to evolve.

Observances differ across the country. The Smithsonian’s National Museum of the American Indian notes that more states are replacing Columbus Day with Indigenous Peoples’ Day, and it names Maine, Oregon, Louisiana, New Mexico, Iowa and Washington, DC among those with official observances. Others continue Columbus Day, and some recognize both.

ObservanceWhat it emphasizesWhy people choose it
Columbus DayColumbus’s 1492 voyage and Italian American heritageTradition, community pride and the history of Italian American belonging
Día de la RazaHispanic identity and cultural blendingA name many Hispanic communities use for October 12
Indigenous Peoples’ DayIndigenous histories, cultures and survivalRecognition of living Indigenous communities and the impact of colonization
Three ways communities observe the second Monday in October; views vary within every community

Those differences reflect an ongoing conversation about how we remember history and whose experiences we choose to acknowledge.

Why This History Still Matters

It’s easy to look at this as a debate about a holiday, but the conversation raises questions that go much deeper. Who gets remembered in our history books? Whose contributions receive recognition? And what happens when the stories we repeat leave out the experiences of entire communities?

Understanding the full story doesn’t diminish our heritage. It helps us understand where we came from and how we became who we are today.

These questions are worth considering, particularly during Hispanic Heritage Month, celebrated from September 15 through October 15. Hispanic heritage includes remarkable achievements in art, literature, music, science, education, entrepreneurship and public life. It also includes Indigenous histories, African diasporic experiences, European influences, migration, resistance and cultural transformation. All of those experiences have contributed to the communities we know today.

What Businesses and Organizations Should Keep in Mind Around Columbus Day

For businesses, educators and organizations that communicate about cultural celebrations, understanding this history is important. Meaningful cultural storytelling takes more than a festive graphic or a familiar slogan. It requires curiosity, accuracy and a willingness to recognize experiences that others have often overlooked. A few simple habits can help:

  • Don’t assume one view: Hispanic and Latino communities hold many perspectives, so avoid messages that speak for everyone.
  • Check your facts: Use reliable sources, and avoid exaggeration in either direction.
  • Listen first: Ask your customers, employees and community partners how they observe the day.
  • Choose respectful language: Name the observance you mean, and avoid festive clichés.
  • Lead with understanding: Share history and context before promotion, or skip the promotion entirely.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why don’t many Hispanics celebrate Columbus Day?

Many Hispanic and Latino people question the holiday because Columbus’s voyages initiated European colonization in the Caribbean, where Indigenous communities experienced enslavement, violence, displacement and devastating population losses. However, views differ across Hispanic and Latino communities, and some do observe the day.

Did Christopher Columbus discover America?

Columbus reached the Caribbean in 1492, but Indigenous peoples had lived in the Americas for tens of thousands of years, according to the Smithsonian’s National Museum of the American Indian. His voyages established sustained contact between Europe and the Americas and accelerated European colonization.

What happened to the Taíno after Columbus arrived?

Taíno communities experienced forced labor, displacement, violence, hunger and European diseases. The Library of Congress notes they were close to extinction by 1550, and a Smithsonian Magazine article describes the loss of about 90 percent of the Native population.

Are there still Taíno people today?

Yes. People and communities today identify as Taíno and maintain or reclaim connections to Indigenous Caribbean heritage. A 2018 genetic study also found Native American ancestry among present-day Puerto Ricans, although scholars debate how to interpret identity claims.

Why was El Morro built in Puerto Rico?

Construction began in 1539 to guard San Juan’s harbor and defend Spanish colonial interests against rival European powers, according to the National Park Service.

Is Columbus Day the same as Indigenous Peoples’ Day?

No. Columbus Day traditionally commemorates Columbus’s 1492 voyage and has historical ties to Italian American heritage. Indigenous Peoples’ Day recognizes Indigenous histories, cultures and survival, and both fall on the second Monday in October where communities observe them.

Why is Columbus Day controversial in Puerto Rico?

Columbus’s arrival preceded Spanish colonization of Puerto Rico and the devastating disruption of Taíno society. For many Puerto Ricans, the holiday raises questions about Indigenous ancestry, colonial history and which experiences people remember.

Is Columbus Day a federal holiday?

Yes. Federal law lists Columbus Day as a legal public holiday on the second Monday in October, and federal law asks the President to issue a proclamation each year. Some states and cities observe Indigenous Peoples’ Day instead or in addition.

Final Thoughts: History Deserves the Whole Story

Christopher Columbus changed the course of world history. His voyages reshaped relationships between Europe and the Americas in ways that continue to influence our world. But those changes didn’t affect everyone equally. For European powers, expansion created opportunities for trade, territorial control and wealth. For many Indigenous communities, it brought displacement, forced labor, disease and violence.

That history is part of the reason Columbus Day remains so complicated for many Hispanics, particularly those connected to Indigenous Caribbean heritage. It’s possible to recognize the historical significance of Columbus’s voyages without overlooking their consequences. And it’s possible to appreciate the cultures that developed in the Americas while acknowledging the suffering that accompanied colonization.

History is rarely as simple as the stories we learned as children. At Elevate It Now®, we believe cultural understanding matters in how organizations communicate, connect and build trust. Our bilingual and bicultural marketing approach helps businesses communicate with authenticity, respect and intention. Explore our bilingual marketing guide or our post on Hispanic Heritage Month to keep learning.

Marketing with Strategy. Branding with Intention.

Let’s Communicate With Authenticity and Respect

Tell us about your business and community, and we’ll help you build a message that honors the people you serve.

No responses yet

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *